Optimize Your Shopify Landing Pages for Conversions: The A/B Testing Guide

Josephine Cheng

Josephine Cheng

In the world of ecommerce, a few clicks can get you virtually anything from anywhere. This revolutionary change means that as a business owner, you need to stay ahead of the competition.

If you’re using Shopify for your ecommerce business, then you're already on the right track. But to truly optimize your store, you should leverage one of the most powerful marketing strategies available to make data driven decisions: A/B testing.

In this guide, we’ll explain what A/B testing is, why it’s crucial for your Shopify store, and how to implement it effectively on your landing pages.

What Is A/B Testing?

A/B Testing Tool on Replo

A/B testing, also known as split testing, is a method where two versions of a landing page or an app are compared to see which performs better. You might also hear it referred to as A/B testing, split testing, A to B testing, AB testing, or A B split testing. Essentially, it’s an experiment to determine which version drives more user engagement and conversions for your target audience.

By understanding what A/B testing can offer, you can utilize this technique to fine-tune various elements of your store—whether it’s the copy, visuals, layout, or interactive components.

How Does A/B Testing Work in Ecommerce?

The core idea behind A/B testing for ecommerce is simple: create two versions of a landing page with different variations of the same element, and compare their performance to identify the most conversion optimized version.

Here’s a step-by-step breakdown on how to run an effective A/B test:

1. Determine What to Test

Choose elements that you think might impact user experience, such as the “buy now” button placement or background color.

2. Create Two Versions

Develop two versions of your page or app with the chosen variations. These variations can differ across mobile app interfaces versus on desktop.

Example: You have two versions of your homepage. Version A has a hero image with a single product, while Version B has a hero image featuring a product bundle.

3. Set Up Tracking

Use Replo’s built-in A/B testing tool or another dedicated AB testing tool to monitor performance metrics. With Replo’s A/B experiments feature, you can customize different variations of a landing page, select the percentage of appearance across audiences for each page variation, and select a winning variant once the experiment is completed.

Any detailed analytics from the A/B test can be ported over to your analytics tool of choice, such as Google Analytics. Key metrics to track include click through rate, bounce rate, time spent on page, and conversion rate.

Replo currently has our own analytics tool in the works and it's launching soon!

4. Compare Results

Once the test concludes, analyze which version performed better for conversions or user engagement.

Example: After running the test for a week, you find that the green "Buy Now" button on Version B has a 20% higher conversion rate than the red button on Version A.

Testing Ecommerce Sites for Conversion Optimization Data On a Laptop

Why Is A/B Testing Important in Ecommerce?

As a Shopify store owner, attracting and retaining customers is your top priority. A/B testing helps you understand your customers' preferences, behaviors, and shopping patterns through a process of elimination.

To start, evaluate your landing page elements, including the effectiveness of copy, layout, graphics, colors, and interactive components. While testing different elements on the page, you can better determine customer’s shopping habits and identify any external factors which may be influencing their decisions.

Through the process of A/B testing, you or your marketing team can gain insight on how to better optimize your landing pages, keeping in mind that the specific page elements to test will differ for each landing page type.

The Importance of Timing in Shopify A/B Testing

Timing really is everything when it comes to A/B test results. To get the most out of your A/B testing, here are some important factors to consider:

1. Customer Shopping Habits

Shopping habits can vary based on the day of the week. Some customers prefer shopping during weekends, while others might shop on weekdays. Tailor your A/B tests to target these different segments.

Example: Test a weekday vs. weekend promotion to see which generates more sales. You might find that weekend shoppers respond better to limited-time offers, while weekday shoppers prefer discount codes.

2. External Factors

Weather, seasons, events, and holidays can impact sales. For instance, holiday seasons often see a spike in sales, making it a perfect time to run A/B tests.

Example: During the holiday season, test different banner designs featuring festive themes to see which drives more engagement and conversions. In areas with warmer weather during the summer, shoppers may prefer to make their purchases in AC-cooled malls rather than online.

3. Window Shopping Behavior

Customers may browse your store and return later to make a purchase. Use A/B testing to determine which elements encourage repeat visits and purchases.

Example: Test different follow-up email sequences to see which one better incentivizes customers to return and complete their purchase.

4. Campaigns and Anomalies

When running campaigns like newsletters, ensure your A/B tests account for these variables.

Make sure that the sample size of your A/B test is large enough to account for any potential anomalies by using segmentation to divide your customers into groups to get accurate results and avoid skewing data.

Example: During a major sale, test different versions of your landing page to see which one converts better, taking into account the influx of traffic from your newsletter campaign.

A Computer Showing the Tracking Results of An A/B Test

How to Run A/B Tests in Your Shopify Store

Here’s a step-by-step guide to setting up A/B tests in your Shopify store:

1. Choose Elements to Test

Focus on one element at a time to get clear results. Aim for higher-impact elements that are likely to get the most exposure or "eye-balls" from audiences, or that are meant to drive visitor action.

Example: Test the headline of your homepage by creating two versions with different headlines.

2. Create Variations

Develop two versions of your page or app.

Example: Version A has the headline “Summer Sale Starts Now!” while Version B says “Save Big with Our Summer Discounts!”

3. Set Test Duration

Ensure you have a significant sample size; aim for at least 100 conversions per version. The amount of time required to collect data may vary depending on the clicks and traffic your pages receive.

4. Analyze Data

Look at conversion rates, click through rates, time spent on page, bounce rate, and other metrics to determine the winner. Setting a conversion goal beforehand is also helpful for benchmarking against a wider set of page variations.

Example: If Version B’s headline results in a 15% higher conversion rate, implement this headline on your homepage.

5. Implement Changes

Apply the winning version’s changes to your landing pages or product pages and continue monitoring for potential fluctuations in metrics.

What Landing Page Elements Should You A/B Test in Shopify?

A Man Analyzing the Results for a A/B Test

1. Copy and Written Content

Test different headlines and body content to see what resonates most with your audience. Consider what type of content best expresses your brand voice and drives towards conversions. For example, you can test “Shop the Best Deals Now!” versus “Exclusive Deals Just for You!”

2. Theme and Colors

Experiment with different themes and color schemes to find the most attractive and brand-aligned combination. An example would be playing around with a light theme versus a dark theme to see which one increases user engagement.

3. Graphics and Visuals

High-quality, eye-catching graphics can make a huge difference. Not only are they vital for engaging the viewer, they should also be able to communicate complex information in a way that is visually appealing and easy to understand.

Make sure to experiment with different designs, animations, and placements to get the most out of your graphics.

4. Layout or Structure

Test different page layouts and structures to see which website layout creates the most user-friendly experience for your customers.

A/B testing on layout and structure could mean testing different placements of your product categories, search bar, and other navigation elements. Additionally, you can alter your website's page layouts, such as including a sidebar or a grid structure.

Lastly, consider how your customers are using your website with the help of heatmaps or session recordings to get an idea of where they click most and what they look at.

5. Interactive and Video Components

Videos such as product demos or customer testimonials, and interactive components such as quizzes, surveys, or mini-games on the site are all helpful for boosting engagement between your brand and the audience. Integrate them into your pages as needed to test which combinations drive the best results.

6. CTA (Call-To-Action)

Calls-To-Action (CTAs) are your key drivers to sales and conversions. When experimenting with CTAs, make sure they are visually appealing and stand out from the rest of the page by using higher contrast colors or bolder fonts. Make sure your text is direct and clear, and avoid using too many words or technical jargon.

Finally, include a specific benefit in your CTA. This can be a discount, free shipping, or even participation in a rewards system to incentivize people to take action.

Best Practices for Landing Page A/B Testing

Last but not least, remember to only test one element at a time for accurate results to determine which variant has the most impact on your conversion rates.

Testing multiple elements simultaneously can lead to inconclusive results, and you may end up not knowing which alteration led to the most significant increase or decrease in your business sales.

A/B Test To Drive Conversions With Replo

A/B testing is a powerful tool that can significantly enhance your Shopify store's performance by helping you fine-tune your landing pages to be the best version possible. By understanding your customers' behavior and tailoring the content of your pages to match their habits, you can optimize your store to drive more traffic and conversions.

Try A/B testing built right into Replo to experiment and learn faster than ever. Now, rather than relying on external tools and integrations, our own build-in testing feature allows you to launch experiments with different page variations in a matter of clicks. Try it out and access a step-by-step walkthrough of A/B testing on Replo with this video tutorial.

Any insights drawn from A/B tests can be quickly implemented in our easy-to-use, no-code drag and drop landing page editor that offers all the flexibility and functions necessary to fully customize your site. It’s tailored to the needs of ecommerce teams and directly integrates with your Shopify store, so you can better turn your pages into an acquisition funnel that converts.

While you can dive into building pages from scratch, we’d recommend leveraging our collection of hundreds of landing page templates inspired by top brands and high converting pages. Browse through them to get started and save time by adapting a template (or however many as you like) for your own site.

Best of all, Replo comes with a community of Experts and Builders for hire and 24/7 support to help you make the most out of Replo. For more informational resources on all topics related to marketing and ecommerce—from comparison shopping engines to dropshipping to Shopify queries—check out our blog!

Visit us to get started, or reach out to schedule a demo with us. Join our Slack community and follow us on X to stay updated.

Get the Latest

Ecommerce interviews and tips delivered weekly

We will never send you spam. Read ourPrivacy Policy.