Skip to main content

Etsy alternatives for sellers

The short answer

Etsy's edge is buyers who already search for handmade. Leave it for lower fees and your shop keeps more: on fifty $20 sales, Big Cartel keeps $956 and Shopify Basic $927, against $883 on Etsy. For other built-in buyers, TikTok Shop takes the least; eBay and Amazon Handmade take more than Etsy.

How we ranked

We ranked by one number: what a seller keeps from fifty $20 sales in a month, after the plan, the platform's fee on each sale and card processing, each read from the platform's own fee page. Each one is on its cheapest plan that takes payments, billed yearly where offered.

US buyers paying by card. Shipping, sales tax, ads (Etsy's Offsite Ads included) and refunds are left out. Marketplaces bring their own buyers; a shop of your own brings none, so you pay to bring them. Replo is ours; we rank it by the same rule.

What you keep from $1,000 in sales

Fifty $20 sales a month, after the plan and every fee, and the same at five times the sales.

  1. 1. Big Cartel

    Gold, up to 5 products

    Keeps from $1,000
    $956
    Keeps from $5,000
    $4,780
    Where buyers come from
    You bring them
    Monthly
    Free; $15 a month for up to 50 products
    Fee on each sale
    None
    Card processing
    2.9% + 30¢ through Stripe or PayPal
  2. 2. TikTok Shop

    Keeps from $1,000
    $940
    Keeps from $5,000
    $4,700
    Where buyers come from
    Viewers of your videos
    Monthly
    None
    Fee on each sale
    6% of the order, processing included
    Card processing
    Included
  3. 3. Shopify

    Basic, billed yearly

    Keeps from $1,000
    $927
    Keeps from $5,000
    $4,751
    Where buyers come from
    You bring them
    Monthly
    $29 a month
    Fee on each sale
    None with Shopify Payments
    Card processing
    2.9% + 30¢
  4. 4. Squarespace

    Core, billed yearly

    Keeps from $1,000
    $927
    Keeps from $5,000
    $4,751
    Where buyers come from
    You bring them
    Monthly
    $29 a month
    Fee on each sale
    0%
    Card processing
    2.9% + 30¢
  5. 5. Etsy

    Keeps from $1,000
    $883
    Keeps from $5,000
    $4,413
    Where buyers come from
    Etsy's shoppers
    Monthly
    None
    Fee on each sale
    6.5%, plus 20¢ to relist
    Card processing
    3% + 25¢
  6. 6. Whatnot

    Keeps from $1,000
    $876
    Keeps from $5,000
    $4,380
    Where buyers come from
    Viewers of your live shows
    Monthly
    None
    Fee on each sale
    8%
    Card processing
    2.9% + 30¢
  7. 7. Replo

    Starter, billed yearly

    Keeps from $1,000
    $857
    Keeps from $5,000
    $4,681
    Where buyers come from
    You bring them
    Monthly
    $99 a month, billed yearly
    Fee on each sale
    None
    Card processing
    Stripe, 2.9% + 30¢
  8. 8. Amazon Handmade

    Keeps from $1,000
    $850
    Keeps from $5,000
    $4,250
    Where buyers come from
    Amazon's shoppers
    Monthly
    None once approved
    Fee on each sale
    15%, 30¢ minimum
    Card processing
    Included
  9. 9. eBay

    Keeps from $1,000
    $844
    Keeps from $5,000
    $4,220
    Where buyers come from
    eBay's shoppers
    Monthly
    None
    Fee on each sale
    13.6% + 40¢ an order over $10
    Card processing
    Included

Etsy counts a 20¢ renewal per sale. eBay's fee is for orders over $10. Big Cartel's free plan holds five products; Platinum is $15 a month for up to 50 products.

Etsy's Help Center article What are Payment Processing Fees for Selling on Etsy

Etsy's help center lists the processing fee for your country next to the 6.5% transaction fee.

Who buys on each marketplace

The buyers each one brings, what it takes to get in, and what sells there.

  1. Etsy

    Buyers
    Shoppers searching for handmade, vintage and supplies
    To get in
    Open sign-up
    Sells well
    Handmade, vintage, digital downloads
    Fee
    6.5% + 3% + 25¢
  2. Amazon Handmade

    Buyers
    Amazon shoppers browsing the Handmade store
    To get in
    Apply and be approved as a maker
    Sells well
    Gifts and home goods you make
    Fee
    15%, 30¢ minimum
  3. eBay

    Buyers
    Shoppers searching listings and auctions
    To get in
    Open sign-up; 250 free listings a month, then 35¢
    Sells well
    Vintage, collectibles, used goods
    Fee
    13.6% + 40¢ an order over $10
  4. TikTok Shop

    Buyers
    People watching your videos and lives
    To get in
    Sign up in Seller Center
    Sells well
    Products that show well on video
    Fee
    6% of the order, processing included
  5. Whatnot

    Buyers
    Bidders in live shows
    To get in
    Apply to sell
    Sells well
    Cards, collectibles, sneakers, vintage
    Fee
    8% + 2.9% + 30¢
  6. Faire

    Buyers
    Independent shops buying wholesale
    To get in
    Apply as a brand
    Sells well
    Goods shops restock in bulk
    Fee
    15%, plus $10 on a new shop's first order; 0% on orders from shops you bring

Faire sells at wholesale, so it isn't ranked above: on a $200 opening order from a new shop, you keep $154.90 after commission, the $10 fee and 2.4% + 30¢ with 30-day payout.

Whatnot's seller page: The future of shopping is live, with a Start Selling button beside a live luxury-bag show

Whatnot's seller page leads with a live show from The Don's Luxury, bids landing in real time.

The right Etsy alternative for each seller

Fees decide less than where your buyers are. Pick by how people will find you.

Best for being found from day one

Etsy

Buyers already search Etsy for handmade, and there's no monthly fee.

Where it loses

Fees on every sale, and the buyer is Etsy's customer, not yours.

Best for a small catalog of your own

Big Cartel

A free shop for up to five products, with no fee on sales.

Where it loses

It brings no buyers, and more products means a paid plan.

Best for a growing product line

Shopify

A full store with sizes, stock, shipping and an app for most jobs.

Where it loses

A monthly plan from the start, and buyers come only from you.

Best for products that sell on video

TikTok Shop

A low fee per sale, with checkout inside the videos people watch.

Where it loses

Sales follow your posting; no new videos, few buyers.

Best for collectibles and vintage

Whatnot

Live shows where bidders compete for each piece in real time.

Where it loses

You have to apply, and selling means going live often.

Best for selling to shops

Faire

Independent shops order wholesale, and shops you bring pay no commission.

Where it loses

You sell at wholesale prices, and Faire takes 15%, plus $10 on a new shop's first order from shops it finds.

Best for vintage and used goods

eBay

Buyers search it for used and vintage, with auctions and free listings.

Where it loses

Its fee on each sale is higher than Etsy's.

Best for gifts with Amazon reach

Amazon Handmade

Amazon's shoppers, with the monthly plan fee waived for approved makers.

Where it loses

A 15% fee, and you must be approved first.

Best for a branded site you drive traffic to

Replo

Builds the site on your brand with checkout, sizes, colors and stock included.

Where it loses

No marketplace buyers, and Starter costs $99 a month, billed yearly.

Keep Etsy, add a site of your own

Many sellers keep their Etsy shop for discovery and send repeat buyers to their own site, where no fee comes off each sale.

  • A site on your brand from a prompt
  • Stripe checkout, no Replo cut
  • Your own domain and buyer emails
  • Analytics on every page
A product page built in Replo: a notebook photo beside its name, a $24 price, color swatches and an Add to bag button

A store page built in Replo: the product, its price and an Add to bag button on the page.

What Replo does for an Etsy seller, and doesn't

Replo builds your own site. It doesn't replace a marketplace's buyers.

Does today

  • Builds a site on your brand from a prompt
  • Stripe checkout with no Replo cut
  • Sizes, colors and stock on each product
  • Your own domain and customer list
  • Analytics and heatmaps on every page

Doesn't do

  • Bring marketplace buyers to you
  • Sync your Etsy listings
  • Subscriptions or point of sale

Frequently asked questions

Why are sellers looking for Etsy alternatives?
Fees and competition. Each sale pays 6.5% plus 3% + 25¢ processing, and Offsite Ads take 12% to 15% of the sale, capped at $100 an order. Etsy's 2025 annual report counted 5.6 million sellers, and buyers spent 4% less than the year before. Etsy still brings 86.5 million active buyers, which no shop of your own does.
What is the best alternative to Etsy for sellers?
It depends on where your buyers are. For other marketplace buyers, TikTok Shop takes the least per sale (6% of the order, processing included), Whatnot suits collectibles sold live, and Faire sells to shops at wholesale. For lower fees, a shop of your own keeps more: on fifty $20 sales, $927 on Shopify Basic against $883 on Etsy.
What sites are like Etsy?
Amazon Handmade is the closest: a marketplace only for items you make, which you apply to join. eBay suits vintage and used goods, Whatnot sells through live auctions, and Faire is a wholesale marketplace where shops buy from makers. Outside the US, Folksy is a handmade marketplace for UK makers.
Is selling on Etsy cheaper than my own website?
Only at small volume. Etsy has no monthly fee but takes about $117 on fifty $20 sales. Shopify Basic costs $73 on the same sales, plan included, and the gap grows with every sale. Try your own prices in the Etsy fee calculator, or see Shopify vs Etsy.
Is Amazon Handmade cheaper than Etsy?
No. Amazon Handmade takes 15%, 30¢ minimum of each sale, card processing included, and waives the monthly plan fee once you're approved. Etsy's 6.5% plus 3% + 25¢ processing comes to less on most prices: $883 kept from fifty $20 sales against $850.
How much does Faire take from a maker?
15%, plus $10 on a new shop's first order, and nothing on orders from shops you bring to Faire yourself. With 30-day payouts, processing is 2.4% + 30¢ with 30-day payout. On a $200 opening order from a new shop, you keep $154.90. Shops pay Faire's wholesale price, which you set below your retail price.
Can I sell on Etsy and my own site at the same time?
Yes, and many sellers do. Etsy brings new buyers; your own site keeps repeat buyers off Etsy's fees and lets you email them. For ideas on what sells, see Etsy shop ideas and how to sell handmade items.

We read every price from the vendor's own pricing page and recheck them. Spot one that changed? Send us a correction.